Nini Squares

Nestled on the outskirts of downtown Fairhope at 451 Magnolia Avenue, Nini Squares has quickly become a local favorite for those craving a fresh take on pizza since its summer 2023 opening. Housed in a charmingly remodeled former home near the Fairhope Public Library, this cozy eatery combines the warmth of a neighborhood gathering spot with the energy of a bustling pizzeria. The inviting exterior features a small lawn for children to play and ample outdoor seating, while the interior buzzes with the aroma of handcrafted pies emerging from the open kitchen.

Specializing in square-cut slices that celebrate both tradition and innovation, Nini Squares operates on a simple philosophy: quality ingredients prepared in small batches. The kitchen team mixes dough daily, hand-slices pepperoni, and chops fresh vegetables to ensure every bite delivers maximum flavor. Patrons can always count on classic cheese and pepperoni slices, while adventurous eaters might find seasonal creations like BBQ chicken, spicy sausage, or veggie-loaded options rotating through the menu. The “sold by the slice” model eliminates ordering dilemmas, making it ideal for groups debating toppings—simply grab multiple varieties to share.

Beyond pizza, the menu showcases thoughtful pairings like crisp mixed green salads with house-made dressings, hearty chopped spinach-romaine combinations, and protein-packed chicken tortellini salads. A daily soup special—whether creamy tomato basil or robust minestrone—complements any meal, available as a standalone or part of a combo. For heartier appetites, customizable pasta dishes let diners build their perfect bowl, starting with red, white, or meat sauce before adding proteins like Gulf shrimp, Italian sausage, or grilled chicken.

The space itself reflects Fairhope’s quirky charm, with booth seating, communal tables, and bar stools encouraging leisurely meals. Large windows flood the dining area with natural light, while the visible kitchen adds theatrical flair as staff expertly maneuver pizzas in and out of wood-fired ovens. Despite the lunchtime rush detailed in local reviews, the team maintains a cheerful efficiency, swiftly clearing tables and offering recommendations to newcomers.

Practical details reflect the restaurant’s community-focused ethos: parking is available on-site and across the street, while hours (Tuesday-Saturday from 11 AM until sold out) prioritize freshness over mass production. This approach has earned a loyal following, with patrons advised to arrive early for the best selection. Seasonal specials and limited-time creations keep the menu dynamic, announced through their active social media presence.

At its core, Nini Squares embodies the spirit of coastal Alabama dining—unpretentious yet inventive, where every element from the house-made dressings to the carefully sourced proteins reflects a commitment to craftsmanship. Whether you’re a local seeking a quick lunch between errands or a visitor exploring Fairhope’s culinary scene, the restaurant’s blend of playful flavors and laid-back atmosphere makes it a must-visit destination. Reach them at (251) 929-8460 to inquire about daily specials or swing by to experience why this pizzeria has become a standout addition to Magnolia Avenue’s vibrant food landscape.

The establishment’s success lies in its balance of consistency and creativity—while the pepperoni slice remains a crowd-pleaser, the kitchen team’s willingness to experiment with bold flavor combinations ensures there’s always something new to discover. From the first bite of their cracker-thin crust to the last morsel of house-baked cookies occasionally featured as desserts, Nini Squares proves that great pizza doesn’t require gimmicks—just passion, quality ingredients, and a dedication to the craft.